๐ Lease vs Buy a Car: Which Costs Less Over 3 and 6 Years?
The dealer will happily show you the monthly payment โ $430.69 to lease, $528.29 to buy โ and let you conclude that leasing is the cheaper deal. It is not, quite: over three years the two cost almost the same, and over six years buying wins by more than $10,000. The monthly payment is the least important number on the page.
This guide runs the full maths on the same $30,000 car both ways โ what you pay each month, what three years really cost, and what six years cost โ then the three traps that decide the answer for real drivers: mileage, wear and tear, and the money factor.
1. Buying: you pay more now, you own something later
Buying is simple: you borrow the price of the car, pay it off in monthly instalments, and the car is yours. Take a $30,000 car with a $3,000 down payment. You finance $27,000 at 6.5% over 60 months, and the payment is $528.29 a month. Over the full five years you pay $31,697.16 โ $27,000 of car and $4,697.16 of interest.
The part people forget is the equity. After 36 payments you have paid $19,018.30 and still owe $11,859.27 โ but the car is still worth about $16,500, roughly 55% of its new price. That leaves you with $4,640.73 of equity: value you own, not money spent. Run your own numbers on our Auto Loan Calculator, and check what payment your budget can carry with the Car Affordability Calculator.
2. Leasing: you pay for the part you use
A lease is different: you do not buy the car, you rent the part of its value you use up. The dealer sets a residual value โ what the car should be worth when you hand it back โ and you pay the difference, plus a finance charge. On the same $30,000 car, a typical 36-month lease looks like this: a negotiated price (cap cost) of $28,000, a residual of $16,500 (55%), and a money factor of 0.0025.
The monthly payment has two parts: depreciation, ($28,000 โ $16,500) รท 36 = $319.44, and the finance charge, ($28,000 + $16,500) ร 0.0025 = $111.25. Together that is $430.69 a month โ $97.60 less than buying. Add $2,000 due at signing and a $350 disposition fee when you return the car. Our Auto Lease Calculator runs the same maths on any car, and the Depreciation Calculator shows how fast the value falls.

3. The 3-year comparison: nearly a tie โ but only one leaves you with a car
Three years in, here is the honest scoreboard on the same $30,000 car:
- Buying: $3,000 down + 36 payments of $528.29 ($19,018.30) = $22,018.30 paid. Sell the car for $16,500, clear the $11,859.27 still owed, and you keep $4,640.73. Net cost of three years of driving: $17,377.57.
- Leasing: $2,000 at signing + 36 payments of $430.69 ($15,505.00) + $350 disposition fee = $17,855.00 paid. You hand the keys back and walk away with nothing.
- The gap is only $477.43 โ the lease costs slightly more, and the buyer still holds a car worth $16,500 with just $11,859.27 owed on it. The lease's lower monthly payment is real, but it buys you nothing at the end.
So over one lease term the two are close. The decision is not really about three years โ it is about what happens next.
4. The 6-year comparison: buying pulls away by $10,012.84
Keep the bought car for six years. You pay $3,000 down and 60 payments of $528.29 โ $34,697.16 in total โ and after six years the car is yours, still worth about $9,000 (30% of its new price). Net cost: $25,697.16, and from year six on, you drive payment-free.
Lease twice instead โ two back-to-back 36-month leases โ and you pay 2 ร $17,855.00 = $35,710.00, and still own nothing. The gap is $10,012.84. Every year you keep a car past its loan, buying gets cheaper; every new lease resets the payment to full price. That is the whole secret: leasing means paying for the most expensive years of a car's life, over and over.

5. Three traps that decide it for real drivers
Mileage. Most leases allow 10,000โ12,000 miles a year. Drive 15,000 miles a year and you owe 5,000 extra miles a year at about $0.25 a mile โ $3,750 over three years โ more than the $3,513.60 the lower payment saves you in that time. High-mileage drivers should almost always buy.
Wear and tear. At the end of a lease the dealer inspects the car and bills you for scratches, dents, stained seats and worn tyres beyond "normal" wear. A few marks can cost hundreds. Your own car has no inspection โ a scuff is just a scuff.
The money factor. Dealers quote a money factor, not an interest rate, because 0.0025 looks tiny. Multiply it by 2,400 to get the real APR: 0.0025 ร 2,400 = 6%. Always convert it and compare it with the loan rate โ if the money factor implies a higher rate than a loan, the lease is the expensive option wearing a cheap disguise. And never put a large down payment on a lease: if the car is written off, that money is gone, while a buyer gets the value back through insurance.
6. The 5-question test
Answer honestly โ then count which side wins:
- Do you drive more than 12,000 miles a year? Yes โ buy.
- Do you usually keep a car five years or more? Yes โ buy.
- Do you modify your car, tow, or drive on rough roads? Yes โ buy.
- Is the lowest possible monthly payment the deciding factor? Yes โ lease.
- Do you want a new car every three years, under warranty, with no repair bills? Yes โ lease.
Three or more "buy" answers: buy the car and keep it. Three or more "lease" answers: lease โ but negotiate the cap cost first, check the money factor, and buy extra miles up front if you need them, because miles bought at signing cost less than miles billed at return.
The 30-second check
Before you sign anything, run your own numbers: the Auto Loan Calculator for the buy payment, the Auto Lease Calculator for the lease payment, and the Budget Calculator to check the payment fits your month. If the lease payment is the only one that fits, lease โ but go in knowing it costs more in the long run. If both fit, buying the car and keeping it is the cheaper road.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to lease or buy a car?
Over three years the two are close: on a $30,000 car, buying costs $17,377.57 net and leasing $17,855.00 โ a $477.43 gap. Over six years buying wins clearly, by $10,012.84, because the buyer owns a car worth about $9,000 while the leaser has paid for two cars and owns neither. The longer you keep a car, the more buying wins.
What is a good money factor on a car lease?
Multiply the money factor by 2,400 to get the equivalent APR: a factor of 0.0025 equals 6% APR. Compare that with the APR on a car loan โ if the lease's implied rate is higher than the loan rate, the lease is the more expensive finance, however low the monthly payment looks.
Can you buy the car at the end of a lease?
Yes. Your contract sets a buyout price โ the residual value, $16,500 in our example โ and you can pay it and keep the car. It can be a good deal if the car is worth more than the residual, or if you love the car and want to avoid a new round of shopping. Check the market value first.
How many miles can you drive on a lease?
Most leases allow 10,000โ12,000 miles a year. Extra miles cost about $0.15โ$0.30 each at return: driving 15,000 miles a year on a 10,000-mile lease costs about $3,750 over three years at $0.25 a mile. If you drive a lot, buy the car โ or buy extra miles when you sign, when they cost less.
References
- All worked figures in this post were computed with the free calculators at metacalculator.org โ Auto Loan Calculator, Auto Lease Calculator, Car Affordability Calculator and Depreciation Calculator (accessed 12 November 2026). Residual values of 55% after 3 years and 30% after 6 years, a 10,000-mile annual allowance and a $0.25 per-mile excess charge are typical figures for a mainstream car, not a guarantee for any specific model โ your contract may differ.
- Related reading on this site: "Rent vs Buy a Home" (22 October 2026) and "15-Year vs 30-Year Mortgage" (5 November 2026).







































