⚔️ Rent vs Buy Calculator
Rent vs Buy Calculator
Renting and buying counted honestly over your stay — rent rises, taxes, insurance, maintenance, appreciation and the sale at the end all in.
The security deposit is not counted in the renting total — it comes back when you move out — but it is tied up for the whole tenancy. Set a return above 0% to count what the down payment could have earned if invested instead.
Net cost of buying: everything you pay in — down payment, payments, tax, insurance, maintenance — minus the equity the sale hands back. Opportunity cost: what the down payment could have earned invested elsewhere. Break-even year: the first year buying’s total drops below renting’s.
Year by Year
| Year | Renting so far | Buying net so far | Ahead |
|---|
Buying starts behind — the down payment and early interest — and usually catches up only after several years. That crossing point is the break-even year.
Buying builds equity but starts with a down payment and years of mostly-interest payments. This calculator totals what buying really costs you over your planned stay \u2014 down payment plus interest paid, minus the principal you get back \u2014 and sets it against total rent for the same period.
The maths ignores home price changes, tax breaks and rent rises, so use the verdict as a starting point and adjust for your local market.
How to use this calculator
Enter the home price, down payment, loan details, monthly rent and how many years you will stay to compare the true cost of buying against renting.
- Type the Home price, Down payment, rate and Loan term.
- Enter the Monthly rent for a comparable place.
- Set how many Years you plan to stay.
- Press Calculate to see which option costs less overall.
Why the answer depends mostly on time
Buying a home has heavy one-off costs at both ends — closing costs when you buy, agent and selling costs when you leave — while renting’s costs are smooth and predictable. In the first few years those one-off costs usually make renting cheaper, even when the monthly payment looks similar. The longer you stay, the more those costs are spread out, and the more your payments build equity instead of covering a landlord’s mortgage. That is why “how long will you stay?” is the first question this comparison asks, and why the break-even year in the results matters more than any total.
Worked example: seven years, both sides counted honestly
Renting: rent starts at $1,800 a month and rises 3% a year, plus renter’s insurance at $15 a month. Over 7 years the total cost of renting is $166,769.18.
Buying: a $350,000 home with 20% down ($70,000) and a loan of $280,000 at 6.5% — payment $1,769.79 a month — plus property tax at 1.1% a year, insurance $150 a month and maintenance at 1% of the home’s value a year. The home grows at 3% a year and is worth $430,455.85 after 7 years; the loan balance is then $253,165.49. After 6% selling costs the net sale brings back $151,463.02 in equity.
Counted fully, buying’s 7-year net cost is $136,118.48 — about $30,650.70 less than renting in this scenario.
Read that result carefully: it is driven by the assumed 3% appreciation and the equity returned at sale. Set appreciation to zero, or shorten the stay to three years, and the same calculation flips to renting. There is no universal winner — there is only your time horizon, your prices and your growth assumptions, which is exactly what the inputs above are for.
The costs people forget on both sides
Buying: closing costs at purchase, property tax, insurance, maintenance (budget roughly 1% of the home’s value a year), HOA dues, and selling costs of around 6%. Renting: annual rent increases, renter’s insurance, the deposit tied up for the whole tenancy, and moving costs each time a lease ends. And on the buying side sits a quiet one: the opportunity cost of the down payment — $70,000 that could otherwise have been invested. This calculator can count it for you; ignoring it flatters buying in every comparison.
Frequently asked questions
How many years do I need to stay for buying to beat renting?
Commonly around five to seven years, because buying’s upfront and selling costs need time to be outweighed by equity and appreciation. The exact break-even year depends on prices, rates and growth — the results above show yours explicitly.
What is the 5% rule I hear about for rent vs buy?
A shortcut that estimates the yearly cost of owning as roughly 5% of the home’s value (about 1% tax, 1% maintenance, 3% cost of capital). If a similar home rents for less than that yearly figure divided by 12 each month, renting is favoured by the shortcut. The calculator above replaces the shortcut with your real numbers.
Does buying always build wealth faster than renting?
No. Buying builds equity in one asset whose value can fall, and early payments are mostly interest. A renter who invests the down payment and the monthly difference can come out ahead, especially over short stays or flat housing markets. The honest comparison counts both — including the down payment’s opportunity cost.
Why does the assumed appreciation rate change the answer so much?
Because the home is bought with leverage: a 3% rise on a $350,000 home is $10,500 a year, which is 15% a year on a $70,000 down payment. Small changes in that one input swing the result more than any other — test your scenario at 0% appreciation before believing the optimistic one.
Should I include my down payment as a cost of buying?
Not as a spent cost — it comes back to you as equity when you sell, and this calculator returns it in the net sale figure. It does belong in the calculation as an opportunity cost: money locked in the home cannot earn investment returns in the meantime.







































